In which I think of lighthouses …

One of my favourite writers is Rosemary Sutcliff. She is really known as a children’s author and I was a child when I first encountered her work. But I have gone back to her every so often as an adult because her themes about love, loss, belonging and courage still speak to me in adulthood as strongly as ever. (Incidentally her novel for adults A Sword at Sunset is the best single volume exploration of the Arthur myth, read it if you can get it.)

‘Hold on,’ you’re thinking, ‘where is he going with this?’ Stay with me a little longer.

Her story The Eagle of the Ninth has been made into a film which will be released in the new year. It’s a fine story that has at its heart a clash between different ways of thinking about the world. The Romans think in orderly straight lines where the British produce art in spirals and curves to express how they see the world. I’ll come back to cultures clashing.

The Eagle of the Ninth is perhaps Rosemary Sutcliff’s most well-known work. But my favourite is the third book in the sequence The Lantern Bearers. It’s set right at the end of Rome’s rule in Britain. At the start of the book the hero, a young soldier, has to decide whether to follow his orders and sail away with his men from the Dover garrison as Rome abandons Britain to fend for itself. In the end his ties to Britain and to his family are too strong so he goes awol.

With his unit already out of the harbour he is drawn irresistibly to the light house dark now for the first time in hundreds of years. Without analysing why he lights the beacon. The last time it will be lit before the dark engulfs Britain. It flares defiantly as he leaves for home to be with the people and places he knows and loves.

It’s a powerful and arresting image. That last flaring of the lighthouse beacon. Signalling the end of the old world but not hailing the arrival of the new. A balefire.

It’s an image that has come back to me often in recent weeks when I have caught up with old friends and colleagues busy with the impacts of the CSR and other government policy changes. One colleague told me his council had decided that his corporate performance team had to go. No one was now interested in bureaucratic accountability: performance indicators and the like. The new world is about putting everything into the hands of everyone and letting the public somehow decide if they are happy with service quality and costs.

And, of course, it’s not just corporate services that face radical pruning. Other colleagues I have seen talk of tussles with councillors and non-executive directors over where to wield the sharp utensils. In each case I sensed a little that same retreat faced by the hero of The Lantern Bearers. A mission ending leaving only empty buildings and the world a little darker as each garrison’s lighthouse beacon burned away to ash and nothingness.

I said I would come back to a clash of ways of thinking about the world. Yesterday’s Guardian Society Daily mentioned a dispute about The Big Society between the anonymous civil servant who writes an excellent column in The Observer and a Conservative local councillor from West Yorkshire. The two pieces make fascinating reading.

The civil servant represents the Roman view of the world. Order, planning, direction. The councillor in contrast is the celt whose dreams are swirls and curves. Bureaucratic accountability against local people taking control over their lives back with complete freedom to do anything or nothing about the problems that surround them.

It feels increasingly to me that an old world is passing quickly now. The legions of state spending have been recalled. The agents of the state left without a mission waiting to be disbanded. The beacons of local public service providers are beginning to go out,  starved of fuel and extinguished. And the country is waiting. In The Lantern Bearers the scars of what happened next dominated the next twenty years of the characters’ lives.

I wonder if it will be the same for us …


About redundantpublicservant

A redundant UK public servant looking for work, sharing his experiences and providing a space for others to do the same.
This entry was posted in CSR2010, Guardian Society, Lantern Bearers, Public sector, Uncategorized, value for money and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to In which I think of lighthouses …

  1. Deborah Parr says:

    Love Rosemary Sutcliffe. And what a cracking analogy. Makes it all feel worse somehow though…….

  2. Mean Mr Mustard says:


    Your end of empire analogy is spot on. The lights are going out all across overspent Europe and America. Complex bureaucracies and empires are now in catabolic collapse. I think it may be worse for those folks remaining, trying to hold things together.

    Mustardus Maximus

    • Salve Mustardus Maximus,

      You make a really interesting point. Civilizations more often than not rot from within rather than without overwhelmed by the weight of their own contradictions. I think you are right about the survivors.

      All the best

      RPS, SPQR

  3. Pingback: Away overseas | Flip Chart Fairy Tales

  4. Superbly thought through analogy. Sword at Sunset was a magnificent read. Yes its all a bit ‘dark ages’ I think, hopefully there are opportunities to set alight some new beacons…..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s